Perceived Sufficiency of Full-Field Digital Mammograms With and Without Irreversible Image Data Compression for Comparison with Next-Year Mammograms
2010

Digital Mammograms: Comparing Compressed and Uncompressed Images

Sample size: 100 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Destounis Stamatia, Somerville Patricia, Murphy Philip, Seifert Posy

Primary Institution: Elizabeth Wende Breast Care, LLC

Hypothesis

Will irreversibly compressed digital mammograms provide sufficient quality for comparison with next-year mammograms?

Conclusion

Irreversibly compressed digital mammograms were found to be as sufficient for comparison with next-year mammograms as lossless-compressed images.

Supporting Evidence

  • 97.37% of lossless-compressed images were perceived as sufficient for comparison.
  • 99.33% of 20:1 irreversibly compressed images were perceived as sufficient in mode 3.
  • The study confirmed the noninferiority of irreversibly compressed images compared to lossless-compressed images.

Takeaway

This study looked at whether digital mammograms that are compressed can still be good enough to compare with future mammograms, and they found that they are.

Methodology

A blinded reader study where 15 radiologists compared 100 digital mammograms in three different modes of compression.

Limitations

The study did not assess the diagnostic accuracy of the irreversibly compressed images.

Participant Demographics

{"age":"58.0 ± 12.3","race":{"Caucasian":"85%"},"breast_tissue_composition":{"almost_entirely_fat":"19%","scattered_fibroglandular_densities":"30%","heterogeneously_dense":"44%","extremely_dense":"7%"}}

Statistical Information

Confidence Interval

98.33%

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1007/s10278-010-9277-6

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication