Analysis of density based and fuzzy c-means clustering methods on lesion border extraction in dermoscopy images
2010

Comparing Clustering Methods for Skin Lesion Detection

Sample size: 100 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Kockara Sinan, Mete Mutlu, Chen Bernard, Aydin Kemal

Primary Institution: University of Central Arkansas

Hypothesis

This study compares the effectiveness of density-based clustering and fuzzy c-means clustering for automatic border detection in dermoscopy images.

Conclusion

DBSCAN outperformed FCM in accurately delineating skin lesions with lower border error and higher precision and recall.

Supporting Evidence

  • DBSCAN achieved an overall average border error ratio of 6.94%.
  • FCM had an overall average border error ratio of 100%.
  • DBSCAN showed higher precision and recall compared to FCM.

Takeaway

The study tested two computer programs to help doctors find the edges of skin spots. One program did a much better job than the other.

Methodology

The study used 100 dermoscopy images and compared the performance of DBSCAN and FCM clustering algorithms based on border error, precision, and recall metrics.

Limitations

The FCM method showed poor performance, especially in border error metrics, and may over-segment images if the number of clusters is not chosen correctly.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1471-2105-11-S6-S26

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication