The Aetiology of Respiratory Tract Cancer in the South African Bantu
1955

Respiratory Tract Cancer in South African Bantu

Sample size: 86 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): P. Keen, N. G. de Moor, M. P. Shapiro, L. Cohen, R. L. Cooper, J. M. Campbell

Primary Institution: Johannesburg General Hospital, South Africa; St. Bartholomew's Hospital, London, England

Hypothesis

The study investigates the differences in the incidence of respiratory tract cancer between South African Bantu and Europeans.

Conclusion

The incidence of carcinoma of the nose and accessory sinuses is significantly higher in the Transvaal Bantu compared to Europeans, while lung cancer is less frequent.

Supporting Evidence

  • Carcinoma of the nose and accessory sinuses accounts for more than half of respiratory tract malignancies in the Bantu.
  • Only 7 cases were considered too advanced for any radical treatment when first seen.
  • Most tumours were well differentiated squamous-cell carcinomata.
  • Heavy cigarette smoking is uncommon in the Bantu population, which may explain the lower incidence of lung cancer.

Takeaway

This study found that Bantu people have more nose and sinus cancers than Europeans, but fewer lung cancers, possibly due to their use of snuff.

Methodology

The study analyzed clinical cases of respiratory tract cancer referred for radiotherapy from 1949 to 1954.

Potential Biases

The selection process for treatment may have introduced bias in the representation of cancer types between racial groups.

Limitations

The study's conclusions may be limited by the selection of patients specifically for radiotherapy, which could differ between racial groups.

Participant Demographics

The study focused on 86 African patients from a population of about 2,000,000 Transvaal Bantu, primarily from rural areas.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication