Variations in clinical decision-making between cardiologists and cardiac surgeons; a case for management by multidisciplinary teams?
2006

Decision-Making Differences in Heart Disease Treatment

Sample size: 53 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Denvir MA, Pell JP, Lee AJ, Rysdale J, Prescott RJ, Eteiba H, Walker A, Mankad P, Starkey IR

Primary Institution: Western General Hospital, Edinburgh

Hypothesis

Are there variations in decisions to revascularise patients with coronary heart disease between general cardiologists, interventional cardiologists, and cardiac surgeons?

Conclusion

There was poor agreement among cardiac specialists in treatment choices, but open discussion improved consensus.

Supporting Evidence

  • Surgeons preferred surgery significantly more than other specialists.
  • Interventional cardiologists favored PCI over other treatments.
  • Agreement among clinicians improved after discussion.
  • Initial voting showed poor agreement (Kappa 0.26).
  • Discussion led to a moderate agreement in the second vote (Kappa 0.44).
  • Variability in treatment decisions was noted among specialists.
  • Some cases showed significant changes in treatment preference after discussion.
  • Overall, the study supports multidisciplinary decision-making in treatment.

Takeaway

Doctors sometimes disagree on how to treat heart disease, but talking about it helps them make better decisions together.

Methodology

Clinicians voted on treatment options for six cases of coronary heart disease, first individually and then after discussion.

Potential Biases

Potential bias due to the self-selection of participants and the specific context of the meeting.

Limitations

The study may not represent all clinical settings as it was conducted in a specific meeting format.

Participant Demographics

53 cardiac specialists including cardiologists and cardiac surgeons.

Statistical Information

P-Value

0.034

Statistical Significance

p = 0.034

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1749-8090-1-2

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication