Factors Influencing Bilateral Investment Treaties with Health Safeguards
Author Information
Author(s): Lu Haohui, Thow Anne Marie, Patay Dori, Tissaoui Takwa, Frank Nicholas, Rippin Holly, Hoang Tien Dat, Gomes Fabio, Alschner Wolfgang, Uddin Shahadat
Primary Institution: The University of Sydney
Hypothesis
What are the characteristics associated with the inclusion of robust health safeguards in BITs?
Conclusion
The study found that mutual connections between countries and economic alignment significantly influence the inclusion of health safeguards in bilateral investment treaties.
Supporting Evidence
- Countries with shared connections are more likely to establish BITs with health safeguards.
- The Common Neighbour centrality feature was identified as a crucial predictor for BIT formations.
- XGBoost model achieved the highest accuracy of 64.02% in predicting BITs with health inclusion.
- Economic indicators like GDP and population ratios were significant in predicting health safeguard inclusion.
- BITs with health provisions foster complex international relations, with countries often having treaties with multiple partners.
- Health safeguards in BITs have been inconsistently implemented, reflecting economic interests and negotiator awareness.
- Network analysis revealed that countries with similar economic profiles are more likely to negotiate BITs with health provisions.
- Temporal analysis showed a shift in feature importance from network-based to economic indicators over time.
Takeaway
This study looks at how countries make agreements to protect health while allowing investments, showing that countries with similar economies are more likely to include health protections in their agreements.
Methodology
The study used network analysis and machine learning techniques to analyze bilateral investment treaties and predict future formations with health safeguards.
Potential Biases
The analysis may overlook critical aspects such as political dynamics and public health priorities.
Limitations
The models rely on the availability and accuracy of economic and network data, which may vary across countries and time periods.
Participant Demographics
Countries involved in the BITs were from various regions, with a focus on those that have established treaties with health provisions.
Statistical Information
P-Value
0.0001
Statistical Significance
p<0.05
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website