A direct comparison of the KB™ Basecaller and phred for identifying the bases from DNA sequencing using chain termination chemistry
2010

Comparing DNA Sequencing Software: KB™ Basecaller vs. Phred

Sample size: 9586 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Hyman Richard W, Jiang Hui, Fukushima Marilyn, Davis Ronald W

Primary Institution: Stanford University

Hypothesis

Does the KB™ Basecaller produce longer high quality DNA sequence reads compared to phred?

Conclusion

The KB™ Basecaller produces longer high quality read lengths than phred, but both software identify the same number of microbial species.

Supporting Evidence

  • The KB™ Basecaller produced a mean read length of 763 bases compared to 731 bases from phred.
  • For reads with at least 500 high quality bases, the KB™ Basecaller produced 804 bases while phred produced 756 bases.
  • Microbe identification was unaffected by the change in software.

Takeaway

This study looked at two software programs that read DNA sequences. One program made longer reads, but both found the same types of germs.

Methodology

The study compared the read lengths and microbial identifications from DNA sequences processed by KB™ Basecaller and phred using statistical tests.

Limitations

The study was labor-intensive and may have differences in results due to different methods for determining read lengths.

Participant Demographics

The study involved DNA sequencing from five women.

Statistical Information

P-Value

<10-15

Statistical Significance

p<10-15

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1756-0500-3-257

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication