Assessing Higher Order Cognitive Skills in Education: MEQs vs MCQs
Author Information
Author(s): Palmer Edward J, Devitt Peter G
Primary Institution: University of Adelaide
Hypothesis
How effectively do modified essay questions (MEQs) assess higher order cognitive skills compared to multiple-choice questions (MCQs)?
Conclusion
Well-constructed multiple-choice questions (MCQs) can effectively replace modified essay questions (MEQs) when MEQs fail to adequately assess higher order cognitive skills.
Supporting Evidence
- Over 50% of MEQs tested factual recall, similar to MCQs.
- MCQs frequently tested more than mere recall of knowledge.
- MEQs failed to consistently assess higher cognitive skills.
Takeaway
This study looked at two types of test questions used in medical education and found that multiple-choice questions are often better at testing thinking skills than essay questions.
Methodology
The study analyzed 50 multiple-choice questions and 139 stages of modified essay questions from three exams over two years, assessing their effectiveness in measuring higher cognitive skills.
Potential Biases
Potential bias in question construction due to lack of formal instruction for authors on how to create effective MEQs.
Limitations
The study's findings may not be generalizable to other institutions due to the specific context of the University of Adelaide.
Participant Demographics
Fourth Year clinical students at the University of Adelaide.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website