In Vivo Comparison of Two Human Norovirus Surrogates for Testing Ethanol-Based Handrubs: The Mouse Chasing the Cat!
2011

Testing Hand Sanitizers Against Norovirus Surrogates

Sample size: 6 publication 10 minutes Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Sattar Syed A., Ali Mohammad Tetro, Jason A.

Primary Institution: Center for Research on Environmental Microbiology (CREM), University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Hypothesis

Is murine norovirus (MNV) a better surrogate for human norovirus (HuNoV) than feline calicivirus (FCV) when testing ethanol-based hand sanitizers?

Conclusion

MNV is more effectively inactivated by ethanol-based hand sanitizers than FCV, especially at shorter contact times.

Supporting Evidence

  • FCV infectivity was reduced by less than 1 log10 after 20 seconds of contact with 62% ethanol.
  • MNV infectivity was reduced by nearly 2.8 log10 after 20 seconds of contact with 62% ethanol.
  • Extending contact time to 30 seconds reduced FCV titer by almost 2 log10.
  • 62% ethanol was found to be a more effective virucide than 75% or 80% ethanol.

Takeaway

This study found that a type of virus similar to the one that causes stomach flu is killed better by hand sanitizers than another type of virus used for testing.

Methodology

The study involved testing the effectiveness of different concentrations of ethanol against FCV and MNV on the hands of adult volunteers.

Potential Biases

Potential bias due to the use of different formulations of ethanol-based hand sanitizers.

Limitations

The study used a commercial hand sanitizer for one test and non-commercial solutions for others, which may affect generalizability.

Participant Demographics

Adult volunteers aged 20-60 years.

Statistical Information

P-Value

p<0.01

Statistical Significance

p<0.01

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1371/journal.pone.0017340

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication