The Relationship Between the Nodular Goitre and Carcinoma of the Thyroid
1962

Nodular Goitre and Thyroid Carcinoma

Sample size: 413 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): P. C. Meyer

Primary Institution: Central Histological Laboratory, Whittington Hospital, London

Hypothesis

The study investigates the relationship between thyroid adenomas and carcinomas.

Conclusion

The study found that a significant proportion of thyroid carcinomas occurred in glands without adenomas, and only a small percentage of carcinomas showed evidence of originating from adenomas.

Supporting Evidence

  • Approximately 6.3% of solitary thyroid nodules were found to be carcinomatous.
  • Over one third of the total number of adenomas occurred as solitary thyroid nodules.
  • The maximum incidence of adenomas occurred in the fifth decade, while carcinomas peaked a decade later.
  • The ratio of female to male cases for adenomas was 8:1, while for carcinomas it was 3.7:1.
  • Only a small proportion of carcinomas showed definite evidence of an origin in an adenoma.

Takeaway

This study looked at thyroid tumors and found that many cancers can happen without any benign lumps, and not all lumps turn into cancer.

Methodology

The study reviewed 113 cases of thyroid carcinoma and 300 examples of thyroid adenoma, excluding necropsy material.

Potential Biases

The diagnostic criteria may vary based on the observer's bias.

Limitations

The study may have selection bias as it only included cases with available histological material.

Participant Demographics

{"age_distribution":{"10-19":7,"20-29":30,"30-39":63,"40-49":83,"50-59":52,"60-69":29,"70-79":11,"80-89":1,"unknown":10},"sex_distribution":{"male":33,"female":266,"not_stated":1}}

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication