Evaluation of visual inspection as a screening test for cervical cancer
1997

Visual Inspection for Cervical Cancer Screening

Sample size: 2843 publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): R Wesley, R Sankaranarayanan, B Mathew, B Chandralekha, A Aysha Beegum, NS Ammal, MK Nair

Primary Institution: Regional Cancer Centre, Trivandrum, India

Hypothesis

Can visual inspection by paramedical personnel effectively screen for cervical cancer in developing countries?

Conclusion

Visual inspection is not a reliable screening method for cervical cancer due to low sensitivity and high non-specificity.

Supporting Evidence

  • Using the lower threshold, 1279 (45%) women were positive on visual inspection.
  • With the higher threshold, only 179 (6.3%) were positive.
  • The sensitivity for detecting moderate dysplasia was 65.8% with the lower threshold.
  • The specificity was 55.3% with the lower threshold.
  • At the higher threshold, sensitivity decreased to 28.9% for moderate dysplasia.
  • Visual inspection detected 92% of invasive lesions at the lower threshold.

Takeaway

Doctors tried using a simple eye check to find cervical cancer in women, but it didn't work very well.

Methodology

The study involved visual inspection and Pap smears on 2843 married women in Kerala, India, with two thresholds for positive tests.

Potential Biases

The results may be influenced by the subjective nature of visual inspection and the training of personnel.

Limitations

The study's sensitivity and specificity were low, and it may not be cost-effective for cervical cancer screening.

Participant Demographics

{"age_distribution":{"under_30":332,"30_to_39":986,"40_to_49":629,"50_to_59":408,"60_and_above":288},"residence":{"rural":198,"urban":2645},"income":{"under_1000_INR":2596,"1000_and_above":247},"occupation":{"housewife":1992,"unskilled_labourers":785,"office_work":66},"education":{"illiterate":612,"primary_grade":1608,"high_school":552,"college_and_above":71},"religion":{"hindu":1500,"christian":930,"muslim":405,"others":8},"age_at_marriage":{"under_14":412,"15_to_20":1860,"20_and_above":571},"number_of_pregnancies":{"none":36,"1_to_2":662,"3_to_4":1150,"more_than_4":995}}

Statistical Information

Confidence Interval

95% CI 50.2-79.8

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication