Science in the Courtroom: Examining Standards for Litigation-Based Research
Author Information
Author(s): Richard C. Dahl, Ronald L. Melnick, Kristina A. Thayer, John R. Bucher, Leslie I. Boden, David Ozonoff, Sheila Jasanoff, Carol J. Henry, James W. Conrad, Jr., William R. Freudenburg
Primary Institution: National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
Hypothesis
Should research conducted expressly for court use be held to higher standards than any other research?
Conclusion
The articles suggest that litigation-based science should not be held to tougher standards than other science, as biases exist in all types of research.
Supporting Evidence
- Conflicts of interest are inherent in science-based litigation.
- Early studies on benzene had poor design and failed to detect carcinogenic effects.
- Many courts have held that litigation-based science is less reliable than other science.
- Judges should focus on the process of generating litigation science rather than its validity.
- Federal agencies have standards to judge the quality of scientific work regardless of its purpose.
- Bias can influence scientists without them being aware of it.
Takeaway
This study looks at how science used in court cases should be treated the same as other science, because all research can have biases.
Potential Biases
Studies funded by corporations may favor their interests, and biases can influence scientists without their awareness.
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website