Critique of University Ranking Systems
Author Information
Author(s): Ioannidis John PA, Patsopoulos Nikolaos A, Kavvoura Fotini K, Tatsioni Athina, Evangelou Evangelos, Kouri Ioanna, Contopoulos-Ioannidis Despina G, Liberopoulos George
Primary Institution: University of Ioannina School of Medicine
Hypothesis
Are current international ranking systems for universities valid and useful in measuring excellence?
Conclusion
Current international ranking systems are misleading and should be improved with standardized evaluations.
Supporting Evidence
- None of the reviewed criteria for international ranking has very good construct validity for educational and research excellence.
- The concordance between the Shanghai and Times rankings is modest, with only 133 universities shared in their top 200 lists.
- Many ranking systems fail to account for institutional size and other critical factors.
Takeaway
This study looks at how universities are ranked and finds that many rankings are not very good at showing which schools are actually the best.
Methodology
The authors reviewed major university ranking systems and assessed their validity based on construct and measurement criteria.
Potential Biases
Potential biases in expert opinion surveys and lack of transparency in ranking methodologies.
Limitations
The study does not provide empirical data from the ranking systems themselves, relying instead on existing literature and web sources.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website