Spheres of Influence: The Price of Gold in Chile
2006
The Pascua-Lama Gold Mine Controversy
publication
Evidence: low
Author Information
Author(s): Scott Fields
Primary Institution: National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
Hypothesis
Will the Pascua-Lama mine be environmentally safe and economically viable?
Conclusion
The Pascua-Lama mine is likely to open despite significant environmental concerns and opposition from local activists.
Supporting Evidence
- The mine is expected to produce significant amounts of gold, silver, and copper over 20 years.
- Local activists are concerned about the potential contamination of water supplies.
- The glaciers covering part of the mine site will not be moved due to new regulations.
- Acid mine drainage poses a serious risk to local ecosystems.
- The mine's permitting process was completed in just 18 months, much faster than typical U.S. standards.
Takeaway
There's a big fight over a gold mine in the Andes because it could hurt the environment, especially the glaciers and water supply.
Potential Biases
The mining company may not be held accountable for environmental damage due to lack of financial guarantees.
Limitations
The permitting process was unusually fast, raising concerns about thorough environmental assessments.
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website