Accuracy of volume measurements by a clinical spirometer in multiple veterinary hospitals
2024

Evaluating the Accuracy of Spirometers in Veterinary Hospitals

Sample size: 67 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Raillard Mathieu, Mosing Martina, Raisis Anthea, Auckburally Adam, Borland Karla, Canfrán Susana, Downing Frances, García de Carellán Mateo Alejandra, MacFarlane Paul, McFadzean William, Merlin Tristan, Portier Karine, Robertson Josephine, Soares Joao Henrique Neves, Steblaj Barbara, Zoff Aurora, Levionnois Olivier L.

Primary Institution: Murdoch University

Hypothesis

Displayed tidal volumes would align with the performance claimed by the manufacturer (±6% or ±4–30 mL, whichever is larger).

Conclusion

The study found that the D-lite flow sensor performed better than the Pedi-lite sensor, particularly for volumes between 300 and 750 mL.

Supporting Evidence

  • Only 37% of measurements with the Pedi-lite sensor met manufacturer specifications.
  • 94% of measurements with the D-lite sensor were within manufacturer specifications.
  • Significant differences were found between inspired and expired volumes for both sensors.

Takeaway

This study looked at how well spirometers measure air volumes in animals during anesthesia, finding that some devices work better than others.

Methodology

The performance of near-patient spirometers was assessed using calibration syringes across 67 monitors in 14 veterinary hospitals.

Potential Biases

High inter-monitor variability may affect the accuracy of spirometry readings.

Limitations

Variability in measurements could be influenced by different investigators and the calibration status of the syringes was not verified.

Participant Demographics

Monitors from 14 veterinary hospitals across six countries were tested.

Statistical Information

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.3389/fvets.2024.1475401

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication