Basal cell carcinoma of the face: surgery or radiotherapy? Results of a randomized study
1997

Surgery vs Radiotherapy for Basal Cell Carcinoma of the Face

Sample size: 347 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): M-F Avril, A Auperin, A Margulis, A Gerbaulet, P Duvillard, E Benhamou, J-C Guillaume, R Chalon, J-Y Petit, H Sancho-Garnier, M Prade, J Bouzy, D Chassagne

Primary Institution: Institut Gustave Roussy

Hypothesis

Is surgery more effective than radiotherapy for treating basal cell carcinoma of the face?

Conclusion

Surgery is more effective and provides better cosmetic results than radiotherapy for treating basal cell carcinoma of the face.

Supporting Evidence

  • The 4-year failure rate was 0.7% for surgery compared to 7.5% for radiotherapy.
  • 87% of patients treated with surgery rated their cosmetic results as good, compared to 69% for radiotherapy.
  • Cosmetic results were significantly better after surgery than after radiotherapy.
  • Only one patient in the surgery group had a recurrence, while 11 patients in the radiotherapy group had recurrences or progression.

Takeaway

Doctors compared two ways to treat skin cancer on the face: cutting it out or using radiation. They found that cutting it out works better and looks nicer.

Methodology

A randomized trial comparing surgery and radiotherapy for primary basal cell carcinoma of the face, with follow-up for 4 years.

Potential Biases

The cosmetic results were assessed by multiple independent observers to minimize bias.

Limitations

The study only included patients with untreated basal cell carcinoma of the face and may not apply to other locations or types of skin cancer.

Participant Demographics

50% men, mean age 66 years, with 5% younger than 45 years.

Statistical Information

P-Value

0.003

Confidence Interval

0.1-3.9% for surgery, 4.2-13.1% for radiotherapy

Statistical Significance

p=0.003

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication