The Role of Metaphor in Reasoning about Crime
Author Information
Author(s): Thibodeau Paul H., Boroditsky Lera
Primary Institution: Stanford University
Hypothesis
Do metaphors influence how people reason about social issues like crime?
Conclusion
Metaphors significantly shape how people conceptualize and approach solving social issues, such as crime.
Supporting Evidence
- Participants exposed to the 'virus' metaphor suggested social reforms, while those exposed to the 'beast' metaphor suggested enforcement.
- Metaphors influenced participants' information-seeking behavior, leading them to look for confirming evidence.
- Even minimal metaphorical changes (like a single word) significantly affected participants' reasoning.
- Participants often did not recognize the metaphor as influential, attributing their reasoning to statistics instead.
Takeaway
The way we talk about crime can change how we think about it, like calling it a 'virus' or a 'beast' can lead to different solutions.
Methodology
Five experiments were conducted to test how different metaphors influence reasoning about crime.
Potential Biases
Potential biases in participant selection and self-reporting may affect the results.
Limitations
The study primarily involved participants from online platforms, which may not represent the general population.
Participant Demographics
Participants included students from Stanford University and Amazon Mechanical Turk users, with a mix of political affiliations.
Statistical Information
P-Value
p<0.001
Statistical Significance
p<0.05
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website