The need for specialist review of pathology in paediatric cancer
1997

Specialist Review of Pathology in Childhood Cancer

Sample size: 2104 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): SE Parkes, KR Muir, AH Cameron, F Raafat, MCG Stevens, BJ Morland, PC Barber, MP Carey, H Fox, EL Jones, HB Marsden, JR Pincott, JAS Pringle, H Reid, Di Rushton, CM Starkie, HL Whitwell, DH Wright, JR Mann

Primary Institution: West Midlands Regional Children's Tumour Research Group, Birmingham Children's Hospital

Hypothesis

Is there variability in the diagnosis of childhood cancer among pathologists?

Conclusion

The study found a high level of agreement among specialist pathologists, suggesting the need for specialist review in childhood cancer diagnoses.

Supporting Evidence

  • The overall level of agreement among pathologists was 90%.
  • Retinoblastoma had a perfect agreement rate of 100%.
  • 16.5% of original diagnoses were amended after review.
  • Specialist pathologists confirmed original diagnoses more often than general pathologists.
  • The study highlights the importance of expert review in pediatric oncology.

Takeaway

Doctors looked at a lot of children's cancer cases to see if they agreed on the diagnoses, and they mostly did, which means it's important to have experts check these cases.

Methodology

A retrospective review of 2104 solid tumour cases was conducted with three independent opinions from a panel of specialist pathologists.

Potential Biases

The original pathologists may have had less access to advanced diagnostic techniques compared to the reviewers.

Limitations

The study did not account for advances in diagnostic techniques that may have influenced the original diagnoses.

Participant Demographics

The study involved cases diagnosed in the West Midlands Health Authority Region from 1957 to 1992.

Statistical Information

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication