Incidental thyroid cancer and overdiagnosis: response to Drs Tsybrovskyy, Sobrinho-Simões, and Tallini
2024

Response to Concerns About Overdiagnosis in Thyroid Cancer

publication

Author Information

Author(s): I Cosme, A Figueiredo, S Pinheiro, V Leite

Primary Institution: Unidade Local de Saúde Santa Maria, Lisbon, Portugal

Hypothesis

Is overdiagnosis the main cause for the rise in thyroid cancer incidence?

Conclusion

A significant proportion of incidental thyroid carcinomas are larger than 2 cm, suggesting that overdiagnosis is likely the main cause for the increase in thyroid cancer incidence.

Supporting Evidence

  • 36% of incidental thyroid carcinomas were larger than 2 cm.
  • 61.5% of patients were completely disease-free at the 5-year follow-up.
  • 30.3% of patients with incidental thyroid cancer had an indeterminate response at the 5-year outcome.

Takeaway

Some thyroid cancers are found by accident, and many of these are bigger than 2 cm, which means they might not be harmless and could be causing more diagnoses than necessary.

Potential Biases

No conflicts of interest were declared.

Limitations

The study does not establish a clear cutoff on tumor size that discriminates between harmful and harmless incidental neoplasias.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1530/ETJ-24-0296

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication