The Effect of Inappropriate Calibration in Molecular Ecology
Author Information
Author(s): Ho Simon Y. W., Saarma Urmas, Barnett Ross, Haile James, Shapiro Beth
Primary Institution: Department of Zoology, University of Oxford
Hypothesis
How does the choice of calibration affect molecular time-scale estimates in ecological studies?
Conclusion
Using inappropriate calibration methods can lead to significantly altered conclusions in molecular ecological studies.
Supporting Evidence
- Three case studies were presented to illustrate the calibration problem in molecular ecology.
- Avian speciation estimates changed significantly when using revised internal calibration rates.
- Bowhead whale demographic history was re-evaluated using ancient DNA, revealing more recent population expansions.
Takeaway
This study shows that if scientists use the wrong methods to measure time in nature, they can get very different answers about how species evolved.
Methodology
The study analyzed genetic data from three case studies to compare the effects of internal versus external calibration methods on divergence time estimates.
Potential Biases
Using deep fossil calibrations may mislead conclusions about recent evolutionary events.
Limitations
The applicability of a single substitution rate across different species may not be valid, leading to potential inaccuracies.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website