What do the JAMA editors say when they discuss manuscripts that they are considering for publication? Developing a schema for classifying the content of editorial discussion
2007

Understanding Editorial Decision-Making at JAMA

Sample size: 102 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Dickersin Kay, Ssemanda Elizabeth, Mansell Catherine, Rennie Drummond

Primary Institution: Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health

Hypothesis

What do the JAMA editors say when they discuss manuscripts that they are considering for publication?

Conclusion

Classification of editorial discourse provides insight into editorial decision making and concepts that need exploration in future studies.

Supporting Evidence

  • The study analyzed 2,376 phrases from editorial discussions.
  • 54% of phrases related to scientific issues.
  • 31% of phrases were about journalism goals important to JAMA's mission.
  • 16% of phrases concerned writing issues.

Takeaway

This study looked at what JAMA editors talk about when deciding whether to publish research papers. They focus a lot on the science, but also on how interesting the results are.

Methodology

An observational study of discussions at manuscript meetings at JAMA, where notes were taken on phrases from discussions surrounding 102 manuscripts.

Potential Biases

The study may reflect biases in editorial decision-making based on the interests and values of the editors.

Limitations

The study did not collect data on manuscripts rejected before the meetings, limiting insights into the rejection process.

Participant Demographics

Most editors were physicians.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1471-2288-7-44

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication