Reliability of Journal Impact Factor Rankings
Author Information
Author(s): Darren C Greenwood
Primary Institution: University of Leeds
Hypothesis
There is uncertainty associated with journal rankings based on the journal impact factor.
Conclusion
Decisions based on journal impact factors are potentially misleading if the associated uncertainty is ignored.
Supporting Evidence
- Most journals cannot be ranked with great precision.
- Only the top and bottom few journals could place any confidence in their rank position.
- Intervals were wider and overlapping for most journals.
Takeaway
This study shows that we can't always trust journal rankings because they can change a lot, and we should be careful when using them.
Methodology
Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo methods were used to estimate the uncertainty associated with journal performance indicators based on citations.
Limitations
The study did not extract information on individual articles, which could provide more detailed insights into citation variability.
Statistical Information
Confidence Interval
95% credible intervals
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website