Participation and Argument in Legislative Debate on Statewide Smoking Restrictions
Author Information
Author(s): Dorie E. Apollonio, Peggy Lopipero, Lisa A. Bero
Primary Institution: University of California, San Francisco
Hypothesis
Is participation in legislative hearings associated with the strength of public health legislation?
Conclusion
Greater participation in legislative hearings is linked to stronger public health legislation.
Supporting Evidence
- Greater participation is associated with stronger legislation.
- Legislative hearings typically draw broader participation than regulatory hearings.
- Public health advocates are seen as persuasive by legislators.
Takeaway
When more people speak up about smoking laws, the laws tend to be stronger and better for public health.
Methodology
The study reviewed legislative testimony from six states regarding Clean Indoor Air Acts and analyzed the relationship between participation and legislative outcomes.
Potential Biases
The analysis may be influenced by the varying levels of participation and the presence of industry lobbyists.
Limitations
The study only included states that kept records of legislative activities, limiting the generalizability of the findings.
Participant Demographics
Participants included local and national advocates, tobacco industry lobbyists, and legislative staffers.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website