Review of Control Procedures in Cervical Manipulation Trials
Author Information
Author(s): Vernon Howard, Puhl Aaron, Reinhart Christine
Primary Institution: Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College
Hypothesis
To characterize the types of control procedures used in controlled clinical trials of cervical spine manipulation and to evaluate the outcomes obtained by subjects in control groups.
Conclusion
Most control procedures in cervical manipulation trials result in small clinical changes, although larger changes are observed in 47% of paired comparisons.
Supporting Evidence
- Most control procedures in cervical manipulation trials do not result in subject blinding.
- Clinical outcomes of these groups were varied with about one third of groups demonstrating a clinically important change.
- The effect of unmasking of control subjects makes the interpretation of the existing clinical trials challenging.
Takeaway
This study looked at different ways to control for treatments in neck pain studies and found that many don't work well, making it hard to know if the treatments are effective.
Methodology
A systematic review of clinical trials was conducted, focusing on control procedures and outcomes in cervical manipulation studies.
Potential Biases
The majority of trials did not report on post-intervention blinding, which may affect the validity of the results.
Limitations
The review did not specify the results of each item of the PEDro scale for each study and did not pool outcomes data due to heterogeneity.
Participant Demographics
The studies included various demographics, primarily focusing on neck pain and headaches.
Statistical Information
P-Value
0.01
Statistical Significance
p=0.01
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website