The effect of attitude to risk on decisions made by nurses using computerised decision support software in telephone clinical assessment: an observational study
2007

Nurses' Risk Attitudes and Decision-Making in Clinical Assessments

Sample size: 265 publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): O'Cathain Alicia, Munro James, Armstrong Iain, O'Donnell Catherine, Heaney David

Primary Institution: University of Sheffield

Hypothesis

Nurses' attitudes to risk affect the decisions they make when using computerized decision support software.

Conclusion

Much of the variation in decision-making by nurses using CDSS remained unexplained, and there was no convincing evidence that nurses' attitudes to risk affected their decisions.

Supporting Evidence

  • 265 nurses responded to the questionnaire, representing a 57% response rate.
  • 16% of calls were triaged to self-care, with significant variation among nurses.
  • 59% of nurses exhibited a 'no risk-taking' attitude to clinical decision-making.

Takeaway

Nurses make different decisions when assessing patients over the phone, and how they feel about taking risks doesn't seem to change that much.

Methodology

Nurses completed a questionnaire about their background and attitudes to risk, and their decision data was analyzed over a six-month period.

Potential Biases

The response rate was lower than expected, possibly due to organizational changes and perceived over-surveying.

Limitations

The instrument used to measure risk attitude may not have been valid, and the study did not account for all factors influencing decision-making.

Participant Demographics

{"gender":{"male":10,"female":90},"age":{"mean":42,"sd":7.1},"nursing_experience":{"less_than_10_years":9,"10_to_19_years":41,"20_or_more_years":50}}

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1472-6947-7-39

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication