Government Inaction on Ratings and Government Subsidies to the US Film Industry Help Promote Youth Smoking
2011
Arguments Against Adult-Rating Movies with Smoking Scenes
publication
Evidence: low
Author Information
Author(s): Simon Chapman, Matthew C. Farrelly
Hypothesis
Should movies with smoking scenes be rated for adults to prevent youth smoking uptake?
Conclusion
The authors argue that adult-rating movies with smoking scenes is ineffective and ignores broader influences on youth smoking.
Supporting Evidence
- Many public health agencies believe that adult ratings would reduce youth exposure to smoking scenes.
- Studies linking movie smoking to youth smoking often fail to control for other influencing factors.
- Teenagers often choose movies based on various attractions, not just smoking content.
- Restricting access to adult-rated movies is unlikely to prevent youth from seeing smoking.
Takeaway
The study says that just because kids see smoking in movies doesn't mean that's why they start smoking; there are many other reasons.
Potential Biases
Potential bias in interpreting the influence of smoking in movies without considering other factors.
Limitations
The arguments presented are based on opinion rather than empirical data.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website