Continued inadequacies in data sources for the evaluation of cancer services
1997

Issues with Cancer Service Data Quality

Sample size: 400 publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): SJ Smith, KR Muir, JL Wolstenholme, KG Thornhill, A Zamorski, K Tolley, RFA Logan, CED Chilvers

Primary Institution: University of Nottingham Medical School

Hypothesis

The study investigates the impact of case note quality and accessibility on the evaluation of cancer services.

Conclusion

The study highlights significant problems with the accessibility and completeness of cancer case notes, which hinder effective evaluation of cancer services.

Supporting Evidence

  • 35% and 39% of case notes were retrieved from the two districts for the 1979-81 period.
  • 46% of case notes overall were destroyed due to health policy.
  • In 1991, at least 96% of case notes could be retrieved across all districts.

Takeaway

This study shows that many cancer patient records are missing or incomplete, making it hard to understand how well cancer services are working.

Methodology

The study examined case notes of breast cancer patients from two time periods, assessing the quality and completeness of the records.

Potential Biases

The destruction of case notes may introduce bias in evaluating cancer service effectiveness.

Limitations

The study was abandoned due to the low proportion and poor quality of available case notes.

Participant Demographics

Women with breast cancer from two time periods and four districts.

Statistical Information

P-Value

0.08

Statistical Significance

p=0.08

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication