An Investigation of the Validity of Death Certification of Cancer of the Lung in Leeds
1959

Validity of Lung Cancer Death Certification in Leeds

Sample size: 1036 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Georgiana M. Bonser, Gretta M. Thomas

Primary Institution: University of Leeds

Hypothesis

The study investigates the accuracy of death certification for lung cancer in Leeds.

Conclusion

The study found that 3.4% of death certificates for lung cancer were incorrectly certified, while 92.5% of clinically diagnosed cases were correctly certified at death.

Supporting Evidence

  • 3.4% of the death certificates were found to be incorrectly certified.
  • 92.5% of clinically diagnosed cases were certified correctly at death.
  • Errors in certification were partly due to ambiguous wording and misdiagnosis.

Takeaway

The researchers looked at death certificates for lung cancer in Leeds and found that most were accurate, but some cases were missed or misclassified.

Methodology

The study involved scrutinizing death certificates and clinical records from two main hospitals in Leeds for the years 1950-54.

Potential Biases

Potential biases may arise from the reliance on clinical diagnoses and the methods used for death certification.

Limitations

The study may not account for all discrepancies in death certification due to coding practices and the timing of autopsies.

Participant Demographics

The study focused on lung cancer cases in Leeds, with a notable discrepancy in certification accuracy between males and females.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication