Comments on the nonpharmaceutical interventions in New York City and Chicago during the 1918 flu pandemic
2007

Comments on Nonpharmaceutical Interventions During the 1918 Flu Pandemic

Editorial Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): John M. Barry

Primary Institution: Center for Bioenvironmental Research, Tulane University

Hypothesis

Did nonpharmaceutical interventions effectively reduce morbidity and mortality during the 1918 influenza pandemic?

Conclusion

The analysis of historical data raises serious questions about the effectiveness of nonpharmaceutical interventions in New York City and Chicago during the 1918 pandemic.

Supporting Evidence

  • Historical records do not mention the use of quarantine during the 1918 pandemic in New York City.
  • Markel's analysis of nonpharmaceutical interventions in 43 cities may not be reliable due to errors in data interpretation.
  • Public health officials in New York City did not report using quarantine or isolation during the outbreak.

Takeaway

This article discusses whether actions taken to prevent the flu in 1918, like quarantines, really worked, and it suggests that the evidence might not support that they did.

Potential Biases

Potential bias in historical reporting and interpretation of data.

Limitations

The commentary is based on historical data, which may not be comprehensive or fully accurate.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication