Numerosity Estimation in Visual Stimuli in the Absence of Luminance-Based Cues
2011

Estimating Numbers Without Luminance Cues

Sample size: 12 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Kramer Peter, Di Bono Maria Grazia, Zorzi Marco, Rustichini Aldo

Primary Institution: Università di Padova

Hypothesis

Can numerosity be estimated in visual stimuli without relying on luminance-based cues?

Conclusion

Numerosity can be estimated almost as well in second-order motion as in first-order motion, indicating that luminance-based cues are not necessary for this estimation.

Supporting Evidence

  • The results showed that numerosity estimation does not rely on first-order spatial filtering.
  • Standard errors increased with estimated numerosity, indicating that subjects were estimating rather than counting.
  • Numerosity estimates were higher in first-order motion than in second-order motion.

Takeaway

People can guess how many shapes are in a picture even when the shapes don't have bright colors, just like they can when the shapes do have bright colors.

Methodology

The study used a novel method based on second-order visual motion to create stimuli that excluded first-order luminance cues.

Limitations

The study only investigated numerosity estimation beyond the subitizing range and did not explore smaller numerosities.

Participant Demographics

12 naïve undergraduates (aged 22–27, 4 women) from the Università di Padova.

Statistical Information

P-Value

p<0.001

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1371/journal.pone.0017378

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication