False Positive Reports in Lung Cancer Diagnosis
Author Information
Author(s): William Umiker
Primary Institution: Veterans Administration Hospital and the University of Michigan Medical School
Hypothesis
The study investigates the occurrence of false positive cytologic diagnoses of lung cancer.
Conclusion
The study found that pseudomalignant cells were most commonly found in patients with chronic pneumonia, bronchiectasis, pulmonary tuberculosis, and chronic bronchitis.
Supporting Evidence
- Pseudomalignant cells were found most commonly in patients with chronic pneumonia, bronchiectasis, pulmonary tuberculosis, and chronic bronchitis.
- The atypical squamous cells originated in areas of squamous metaplasia of bronchial epithelium.
- Some variants of squamous metaplastic cells, hyperplastic respiratory columnar cells, and 'Pap' cells are probably cytologic expressions of inflammatory or premalignant dysplasia.
Takeaway
Sometimes, tests for lung cancer can mistakenly show cancer when there isn't any, especially in people with certain lung diseases.
Methodology
The study examined smears of sputum or bronchial secretions from 217 patients for malignant cells.
Limitations
The study did not demonstrate a constant relationship between cell type and the nature of the disease process.
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website