Liquid vs Gel Handrub for Hand Hygiene
Author Information
Author(s): Traore Ousmane, Hugonnet Stéphane, Lübbe Jann, Griffiths William, Pittet Didier
Primary Institution: University of Geneva Hospitals
Hypothesis
Does the introduction of a gel formulation lead to increased compliance with hand hygiene among healthcare workers?
Conclusion
Facilitated access to an alcohol-based gel formulation leads to improved compliance with hand hygiene and better skin condition in healthcare workers.
Supporting Evidence
- Overall compliance with hand hygiene practices was 39.1% among nurses.
- Compliance improved significantly when the alcohol-based formulation was available in the HCW's pocket.
- The gel formulation performed significantly better than the liquid formulation in terms of skin condition.
Takeaway
Using a gel hand sanitizer instead of a liquid one helps doctors and nurses clean their hands better and keeps their skin healthier.
Methodology
A prospective intervention study comparing compliance with liquid and gel handrub formulations among healthcare workers in an ICU.
Potential Biases
Potential bias due to the observer not being concealed and HCWs possibly changing behavior because they were being observed.
Limitations
The study was not blinded, and observation bias may have influenced compliance estimates.
Participant Demographics
102 healthcare workers including nurses, physicians, and nursing assistants in a medical intensive care unit.
Statistical Information
P-Value
0.027
Confidence Interval
95% CI
Statistical Significance
p<0.05
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website