Firm, yet flexible: a fidelity debate paper with two case examples
2024

Balancing Firmness and Flexibility in Healthcare Implementation

publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Bianca Albers, Lotte Verweij, Kathrin Blum, Saskia Oesch, Marie-Therese Schultes, Lauren Clack, Rahel Naef

Primary Institution: Institute for Implementation Science in Health Care, Universitätstrasse 84, Zurich, Switzerland

Hypothesis

How can fidelity to adaptive complex health interventions be operationalized and assessed to ensure that interventions are applied as intended while creating an optimal fit between the intervention, its users, and the setting in which it is delivered?

Conclusion

Contemporary fidelity concepts require a balance between strict adherence to intervention protocols and the flexibility to adapt to local contexts.

Supporting Evidence

  • Fidelity is crucial for interpreting the results of complex healthcare interventions.
  • Flexibility in fidelity allows for better adaptation to local contexts.
  • Current frameworks for assessing fidelity need to include organizational and system-level factors.

Takeaway

This study talks about how important it is to stick to the rules when helping people in healthcare, but also to be able to change those rules a little to make sure everyone gets the best help.

Methodology

The paper discusses two ongoing hybrid effectiveness-implementation trials to explore the balance between fidelity and flexibility in healthcare interventions.

Potential Biases

There is a risk of bias due to self-reported measures and the subjective nature of defining fidelity requirements.

Limitations

The study highlights the complexity of measuring fidelity and the need for more validated tools to assess fidelity in adaptive interventions.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/s13012-024-01406-3

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication