Communicating Diagnostic Uncertainty in Safety-Netting
Author Information
Author(s): Caitríona Cox, Thea Hatfield, Zoë Fritz
Primary Institution: The Healthcare Improvement Studies Institute, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
Hypothesis
How and why do doctors communicate diagnostic uncertainty when safety-netting?
Conclusion
Doctors safety-netted variously, often without explicitly discussing diagnostic uncertainty, which may limit the effectiveness of safety-netting.
Supporting Evidence
- Safety-netting was common but varied significantly among doctors.
- Many doctors did not explicitly discuss diagnostic uncertainty when safety-netting.
- Concerns about causing patient anxiety influenced how uncertainty was communicated.
Takeaway
Doctors sometimes tell patients to come back if they feel worse, but they don't always explain that their diagnosis might not be correct, which could lead to problems.
Methodology
Doctors were given clinical vignettes and interviewed about their safety-netting practices.
Potential Biases
Social desirability bias may have influenced participants' responses.
Limitations
The study used hypothetical vignettes, which may not reflect real-life consultations.
Participant Demographics
{"gender":{"female":18,"male":18},"ethnicity":{"white":19,"mixed":2,"asian":15,"black":0,"arab":0,"other":0},"grade":{"consultant":10,"registrar":10,"core trainee":9,"foundation doctor":7}}
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website