Effects of Smoke from 'Safer' Cigarettes
Author Information
Author(s): J.M. Hopkin, H.J. Evans
Primary Institution: Department of Medicine, University of Birmingham; MRC Clinical Population Cytogenetics Unit, Edinburgh
Hypothesis
Do lower tar cigarettes have similar mutagenic and cytotoxic effects as conventional cigarettes?
Conclusion
The study found that smoke from lower tar cigarettes has similar harmful effects as that from higher tar cigarettes.
Supporting Evidence
- Lower tar cigarettes produce similar mutagenic effects as higher tar cigarettes.
- Smokers tend to inhale more deeply from lower tar cigarettes to compensate for lower nicotine.
- Induced sister chromatid exchanges are associated with lung cancer risk.
Takeaway
Even though some cigarettes are labeled as 'safer' because they have less tar, they can still be just as harmful to your health.
Methodology
The study assessed mutagenicity and cytotoxicity of cigarette smoke condensates from various types of cigarettes using human cells in vitro.
Potential Biases
Potential bias due to the small sample size and the selection of healthy non-smokers.
Limitations
The study was limited to a small number of healthy non-smokers and may not represent the effects on smokers.
Participant Demographics
2 healthy non-smoking males aged 30 years for mutagenicity; 6 healthy non-smoking males aged 25-35 years for cytotoxicity.
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website