Case report: potential arsenic toxicosis secondary to herbal kelp supplement
2007

Organic versus Inorganic Arsenic in Herbal Kelp Supplements

publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): Amster E, Tiwary A, Schenker MB

Hypothesis

Is there a link between arsenic toxicity and the ingestion of a kelp-based supplement?

Conclusion

The study suggests that the arsenic found in kelp is not responsible for the medical conditions observed in the patient.

Supporting Evidence

  • The symptoms described in the patient are not characteristic of arsenic toxicity.
  • Normal urinary arsenic levels can be significantly elevated after seafood consumption.
  • Organic arsenic compounds are generally much less toxic than inorganic arsenic.

Takeaway

The study looked at whether arsenic in kelp supplements could make someone sick, but it turns out that the type of arsenic in kelp is usually not harmful.

Methodology

The authors used urinary arsenic levels to estimate exposure and compared it to normal levels.

Potential Biases

The authors drew misleading comparisons between arsenic levels in the supplement and regulatory limits.

Limitations

The study did not quantify arsenic intake and failed to consider iodine toxicity or the patient's pre-existing conditions.

Participant Demographics

The study focused on a single patient with symptoms after taking the supplement.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1289/ehp.10472

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication