Comparing Audit Methods and Secondary Data for Health Assessment in Brazilian Cities
Author Information
Author(s): Cafruni Cristina Borges, Garcez Anderson, Backes Vanessa, Henn Ruth Liane, de Bairros Fernanda Souza, Dias-da-Costa Juvenal Soares, Olinto Maria Teresa Anselmo
Primary Institution: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul
Hypothesis
Does the agreement between audit methods and secondary data sources for assessing health-related characteristics of the built environment differ according to neighborhood income levels?
Conclusion
The study found that while there was generally good agreement between audit and secondary data, this agreement was poorer in low-income neighborhoods.
Supporting Evidence
- Agreement between audit and secondary data was good or excellent for most categories.
- Lower income neighborhoods showed worse agreement in three of five categories.
- Secondary data should be used with caution in assessing health-related characteristics in poorer areas.
Takeaway
The study looked at how well two different ways of checking health-related features in neighborhoods matched up, and found that poorer neighborhoods had more problems with the data.
Methodology
An ecological study was conducted using systematic random sampling of census tracts and homes, followed by audits and secondary data analysis using ArcGIS.
Potential Biases
Potential classification errors by auditors and the presence of unregistered businesses in low-income neighborhoods may bias results.
Limitations
The study did not crosscheck each establishment found by the audit with the secondary data, which limited the identification of causes for agreement variance.
Participant Demographics
The study focused on adult women aged 20-69 in São Leopoldo, Brazil.
Statistical Information
Confidence Interval
95% CI
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website