Comparing Self-Reported and Measured Body Size and Reproductive Factors
Author Information
Author(s): Cairns Benjamin J, Liu Bette, Clennell Suzanne, Cooper Rachel, Reeves Gillian K, Beral Valerie, Kuh Diana
Primary Institution: Cancer Epidemiology Unit, University of Oxford
Hypothesis
How do self-reported data on body size and reproductive history compare to measured values in middle-aged women?
Conclusion
Self-reported data on certain anthropometric and reproductive factors may be adequate for describing disease-exposure associations in large epidemiological studies, but should be interpreted with caution.
Supporting Evidence
- Self-reported data on height, weight, and body mass index were very strongly correlated with measured values.
- Regression dilution ratios indicated slight to moderate attenuation of disease-exposure estimates due to reporting errors.
- Self-reported data on reproductive history showed moderate to excellent agreement with measured data.
Takeaway
This study looked at how well women remember their body size and reproductive history. It found that their memories are often pretty good, but sometimes they make mistakes.
Methodology
The study compared self-reported data from the Million Women Study with measured data from the National Survey of Health and Development for 541 women.
Potential Biases
Self-reported data may be biased, particularly with under-reporting of weight among heavier individuals.
Limitations
The study may not generalize to all populations, and self-reported data can contain both random and systematic errors.
Participant Demographics
Participants were middle-aged women, primarily from the UK.
Statistical Information
P-Value
0.01
Confidence Interval
0.66-0.86
Statistical Significance
p<0.05
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website