Critique of High-Risk Caries Prevention Strategy in Schoolchildren
Author Information
Author(s): Paul A Batchelor, Aubrey Sheiham
Primary Institution: University College London
Hypothesis
Do 'high risk groups' of children account for a high percentage of new caries lesions in children?
Conclusion
The study found that the majority of new caries lesions occurred in children classified at the lowest caries risk, challenging the high-risk strategy for caries prevention.
Supporting Evidence
- Children classified as 'highest risk' contributed less than 6% of the total number of new lesions developing over 4 years.
- Over 50% of the total number of new lesions occurred in individuals with an initial DMF-S score of 0.
- The majority of new lesions were in children classified at the lowest risk, irrespective of the preventive regime.
Takeaway
Most new cavities in kids happen to those who are not considered at high risk, which means we should focus on everyone, not just the few kids who seem most likely to get cavities.
Methodology
Data were derived from the National Preventive Dentistry Demonstration Programme, analyzing new carious lesions over a 4-year period in four groups of 7-year-old children with different preventive regimes.
Potential Biases
The methods used to identify high-risk children were noted to have low accuracy.
Limitations
The study did not assess the impact of non-respondents from the original project.
Participant Demographics
Children aged 7 years from 10 communities in the United States, with varying fluoridation and sealant status.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website