Impact of discussion on preferences elicited in a group setting
2006

Impact of Discussion on Preferences in a Group Setting

Sample size: 15 publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): Ken Stein, Julie Ratcliffe, Ali Round, Ruairidh Milne, John E Brazier

Primary Institution: Peninsula Technology Assessment Group, Peninsula Medical School, Universities of Exeter and Plymouth

Hypothesis

Facilitated discussion in a small group would result in no changes by individuals and no significant changes in the summary utilities from the group.

Conclusion

Discussion did not result in substantial changes to preferences, suggesting that incompleteness may not significantly affect cost-utility analyses.

Supporting Evidence

  • Sixteen changes (3.6%) were made to preferences by seven (47%) of the fifteen members.
  • The average effect on the group mean was 0.0053.
  • No differences before and after discussion were statistically significant.
  • The group valued discussion highly for reassurance, improved performance, increased cohesion, and satisfying curiosity.

Takeaway

When people talk about their choices in a group, they don't change their minds much, but they still find it helpful to discuss.

Methodology

Fifteen non-health professionals were recruited to discuss and evaluate 41 health scenarios over five meetings, with preferences elicited before and after discussion.

Potential Biases

Potential social desirability bias may have influenced participants' willingness to change their preferences.

Limitations

The study had a small, homogeneous sample and low statistical power for individual comparisons.

Participant Demographics

{"mean_age":64,"sex_distribution":{"male":9,"female":5},"marital_status":{"married":13,"widowed":2},"occupation":{"retired":8,"working_part_time":7},"ethnicity":"White"}

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1477-7525-4-22

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication