Comparison of the Performance of ICP-MS, CV-ICP-OES, and TDA AAS in Determining Mercury in Marine Sediment Samples
2024

Comparing Methods for Measuring Mercury in Marine Sediments

Sample size: 8 publication 10 minutes Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Provete Carolina S., Dalfior Bruna M., Mantovaneli Rafael, Carneiro Maria Tereza W., Brandão Geisamanda P.

Primary Institution: Laboratory of Atomic Spectrometry (LEA), Chemistry Department, Federal University of Espírito Santo, Vitória, Espírito Santo, Brazil

Hypothesis

This study aims to compare the effectiveness of ICP-MS, CV-ICP-OES, and TDA AAS in determining mercury levels in marine sediment samples.

Conclusion

The study found that ICP-MS and TDA AAS are suitable for monitoring low levels of mercury in marine sediments, while CV-ICP-OES has limitations due to a high method limit of quantification.

Supporting Evidence

  • ICP-MS showed the lowest method limit of quantification at 1.9 μg kg–1.
  • TDA AAS had a method limit of quantification of 0.35 μg kg–1.
  • CV-ICP-OES could not determine mercury levels due to a high limit of quantification of 165 μg kg–1.
  • Statistical tests indicated no significant difference between mercury concentrations measured by ICP-MS and TDA AAS.
  • All methods were evaluated against certified reference materials for accuracy.

Takeaway

Scientists tested three different methods to measure mercury in ocean mud, and found that two methods worked well, but one couldn't measure low levels of mercury.

Methodology

The study compared three analytical techniques: ICP-MS, CV-ICP-OES, and TDA AAS, using marine sediment samples and certified reference materials.

Limitations

The CV-ICP-OES method had a high limit of quantification, making it unsuitable for detecting low mercury levels.

Statistical Information

P-Value

1.9

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1021/acsomega.4c06144

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication