On the Death Rates from Cancer of the Stomach and Respiratory Diseases in 1949-53 Among Coal Miners and Other Male Residents in Counties of England and Wales
1962

Cancer Death Rates in Coal Miners

Sample size: 472062 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): P. Stocks

Primary Institution: University College of North Wales School of Agriculture

Hypothesis

Does occupation and environment affect mortality rates from stomach cancer and respiratory diseases among coal miners compared to non-miners?

Conclusion

Coal miners have higher mortality rates from stomach cancer and respiratory diseases compared to non-miners, with significant regional variations.

Supporting Evidence

  • Coal miners showed a standardized mortality ratio of 149 for stomach cancer compared to non-miners.
  • Bronchitis mortality was significantly higher in coal miners, with a standardized mortality ratio of 135.
  • Regional differences in mortality rates were observed, with the highest rates in South Wales.

Takeaway

Coal miners are more likely to die from stomach cancer and breathing problems than people who don't work in coal mining.

Methodology

The study compared death rates from stomach cancer and respiratory diseases between coal miners and non-miners in various counties using mortality statistics from 1949-53.

Potential Biases

Potential bias due to the lack of regional subdivision in mortality data for miners' wives.

Limitations

The study did not account for all local factors affecting mortality rates and lacked detailed subdivision by occupation for married women's mortality.

Participant Demographics

Males aged 20-64 from various coal mining areas in England and Wales.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication