Aligning rhetoric with reality: a qualitative analysis of multistakeholder initiatives in the global food system
2024

Challenges of Multistakeholder Initiatives in Global Food Governance

Sample size: 31 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): van den Akker Amber, Gilmore Anna B, Fabbri Alice, Knai Cecile, Rutter Harry

Primary Institution: University of Bath

Hypothesis

What are the challenges related to the input legitimacy of multistakeholder initiatives in the global food system?

Conclusion

Multistakeholder initiatives face significant challenges that limit their ability to establish and maintain legitimate governance processes.

Supporting Evidence

  • Participants noted significant challenges related to inclusiveness and power asymmetries in multistakeholder initiatives.
  • Many MSIs struggled to be inclusive, facing barriers that excluded marginalized actors.
  • Power imbalances influenced the processes and structures of MSIs, complicating goal-setting.
  • Reliance on informal processes limited transparency and accountability in MSIs.

Takeaway

This study looked at how groups working together to improve food systems often struggle to include everyone fairly and make decisions together.

Methodology

Qualitative analysis of interview data with 31 participants working in or on multistakeholder initiatives.

Potential Biases

Participants from powerful sectors may have influenced the discussions, leading to potential bias in the findings.

Limitations

The study focused only on the rationales for legitimacy without including outcomes and relied solely on interview data.

Participant Demographics

Participants included individuals from various sectors, including academia, NGOs, and the private sector, with a majority based in Europe.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1093/heapro/daae165

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication