Surgical Techniques in Nontraumatic Midcarpal Instability: Evaluating the Dorsal Capsulodesis and 3-Ligament Tenodesis Technique
2024

Surgical Techniques for Midcarpal Instability

Sample size: 112 publication 10 minutes Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Hakkesteegt Stefanie N. MD, Jongen Isabel C. MD, Hundepool Caroline A. MD, PhD, van der Oest Mark J. W. MD, PhD, Duraku Liron S. MD, PhD, Feitz Reinier MD, PhD, Zuidam J. Michiel MD, PhD

Primary Institution: Erasmus Medical Center

Hypothesis

This study aimed to assess and compare differences in patient-reported pain, hand and wrist function, satisfaction, range of motion, and return to work in patients with nontraumatic midcarpal instability who underwent surgical treatment either through dorsal wrist capsulodesis or 3-ligament tenodesis.

Conclusion

Both 3LT and dorsal capsulodesis demonstrate promising results for addressing nontraumatic midcarpal instability, with dorsal capsulodesis offering quicker recovery and faster return to work.

Supporting Evidence

  • At 12 months postoperatively, both treatment groups reported significant improvements in pain and function scores.
  • The dorsal capsulodesis group exhibited significantly better outcomes at 3 months postoperatively.
  • The return-to-work rate was higher in the dorsal capsulodesis group (72%) compared to the 3LT group (50%).
  • Both surgical techniques showed promising results for treating nontraumatic midcarpal instability.

Takeaway

Doctors compared two surgeries for wrist problems and found that one surgery helped people get better faster than the other.

Methodology

Patients with nontraumatic midcarpal instability treated with either dorsal capsulodesis or 3-ligament tenodesis were included, and outcomes were assessed at 3 and 12 months postoperatively.

Potential Biases

The choice of surgical treatment was based on the surgeon's preference rather than patient characteristics, which may introduce bias.

Limitations

The study did not document hypermobility scores for most patients, which could affect outcome assessments.

Participant Demographics

The patient population was predominantly female, with a mean age of 30 years for the capsulodesis group and 32 years for the 3LT group.

Statistical Information

P-Value

0.045

Confidence Interval

95%

Statistical Significance

p<0.05

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1097/PRS.0000000000011489

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication