Comparability of Weighed Dietary Records and a Self-Administered Diet History Questionnaire for Estimating Monetary Cost of Dietary Energy
2008

Comparing Dietary Cost Estimation Methods

Sample size: 184 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Murakami Kentaro, Sasaki Satoshi, Takahashi Yoshiko, Okubo Hitomi, Hirota Naoko, Notsu Akiko, Fukui Mitsuru, Date Chigusa

Primary Institution: University of Tokyo

Hypothesis

How comparable are the monetary costs of dietary energy estimated from weighed dietary records and a self-administered diet history questionnaire?

Conclusion

The study found reasonable comparability of monetary cost of dietary energy across dietary assessment methods.

Supporting Evidence

  • The study compared monetary costs of dietary energy from two different dietary assessment methods.
  • Pearson correlations indicated reasonable agreement between the two methods.
  • Mean differences in dietary cost estimates were within 10%.

Takeaway

This study looked at how much people spend on food using two different methods and found that both methods give similar results.

Methodology

The study involved 92 women and 92 men completing both a diet history questionnaire and weighed dietary records over a year.

Potential Biases

Potential measurement errors in both dietary assessment methods could affect the results.

Limitations

The study lacks true measures of monetary diet cost and may not be generalizable due to the specific population studied.

Participant Demographics

Participants were 92 Japanese women aged 31-69 and 92 Japanese men aged 32-76.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication