Surgery and salvation: the roots of reproductive injustice in Mexico (1770-1940)
2024

Religious Paternalism and Racial Prejudice in Obstetric Surgery in Mexico

publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Elizabeth O’Brien

Primary Institution: Texas Christian University

Hypothesis

How did theological debates about fetal personhood influence reproductive surgery and racial disparities in maternal health in Mexico?

Conclusion

The study reveals that religious and racial biases have historically shaped obstetric practices, leading to significant injustices against marginalized women in Mexico.

Supporting Evidence

  • Obstetric violence disproportionately affects poor and racially marginalized women.
  • Theological debates about fetal personhood have historically influenced medical practices.
  • Cesarean surgery was often prioritized over the health of the mother.
  • Marginalized women were targeted for experimental surgeries in the name of medical advancement.
  • Religious paternalism legitimized surgical interventions that harmed women's health.

Takeaway

This study shows that in the past, doctors often prioritized the unborn over the health of mothers, especially if they were poor or from certain racial backgrounds.

Methodology

The book examines historical surgical practices and their theological underpinnings through a chronological analysis of obstetric surgery in Mexico.

Potential Biases

The study may reflect biases inherent in historical interpretations of medical practices and theological discourses.

Participant Demographics

The focus is on impoverished and racially marginalized women in Mexico.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1590/S0104-59702024000100069

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication