Discrepancy Between Chargemaster Prices and Hospital Quality for Cataract Surgery
Author Information
Author(s): Muacevic Alexander, Adler John R, Morrison Avery, Amin Abha, Park Steve, Branco Joseph, Chaudhary Richard S, Ahluwalia Jai, Grimes Cara L
Primary Institution: New York Medical College
Hypothesis
Is there a relationship between listed chargemaster prices and hospital characteristics or quality for cataract surgery?
Conclusion
Cataract surgery prices varied significantly across the five states chosen, with the highest quality hospitals having the lowest listed prices.
Supporting Evidence
- Price listings for cataract procedures differed significantly across the five states included in our analysis.
- California hospitals had the highest median price listed at $3,240.0, while Ohio hospitals had the lowest at $1,268.6.
- The highest quality hospitals (CMS star ranking of 5) had the lowest median price listed at $1,938.0.
- General acute care hospitals had the highest median price listed at $2,370.1.
- State and local government hospitals had the highest median prices listed at $3,254.8 and $4,059.4 respectively.
Takeaway
This study found that cataract surgery prices are very different depending on where you go, and sometimes the best hospitals charge less.
Methodology
A cross-sectional study analyzing chargemaster prices for cataract surgery from hospitals in five states.
Potential Biases
Chargemaster prices are often a starting point for negotiations and may not reflect actual costs paid by patients.
Limitations
Chargemaster prices may not include all costs associated with cataract surgery and can vary significantly from final bills.
Participant Demographics
Hospitals from California, Massachusetts, Mississippi, New York, and Ohio were included, representing diverse healthcare regions.
Statistical Information
P-Value
<0.001
Statistical Significance
p<0.001
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website