Conveying misinformation: Top-ranked Japanese books on tobacco
2011

Misinformation in Japanese Tobacco Books

Sample size: 17 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Kanamori Yuko, Malone Ruth E

Primary Institution: University of California, San Francisco

Hypothesis

What types of misinformation about tobacco are conveyed in popular Japanese books?

Conclusion

Pro-smoking books in Japan create doubt about the dangers of smoking and may mislead readers.

Supporting Evidence

  • Nine out of 17 books reviewed were pro-smoking.
  • Pro-smoking books conveyed misinformation about the health effects of smoking.
  • Some authors were former employees of Japan Tobacco.
  • Books suggested that smoking could be beneficial for health and longevity.
  • Pro-smoking narratives were linked to cultural and historical contexts.

Takeaway

Some popular books in Japan say smoking is not harmful and can even be good for you, which is not true.

Methodology

The authors analyzed the top 12 books about tobacco on Amazon Japan, classifying them as pro-smoking, anti-smoking, or neutral.

Potential Biases

Some authors may have connections to the tobacco industry, which could influence their perspectives.

Limitations

The study examined a small number of books, which may not represent all books about tobacco in Japan.

Participant Demographics

The books reviewed were popular among Japanese readers interested in tobacco.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1617-9625-9-3

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication