Long-term psychosocial impact of alternative management policies in women with low-grade abnormal cervical cytology referred for colposcopy: a randomised controlled trial
2011

Psychosocial Impact of Management Policies in Women at Colposcopy

Sample size: 989 publication 10 minutes Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Linda Sharp, Seonaidh Cotton, Nicola Gray, Mark Avis, Ian Russell, Leslie Walker, Norman Waugh, David Whynes, Claire Woolley, Alison Thornton, Maggie Cruickshank, Julian Little

Primary Institution: University of Aberdeen

Hypothesis

What are the psychosocial outcomes of different management policies for women with low-grade abnormal cervical cytology referred for colposcopy?

Conclusion

There is no difference in long- or short-term psychosocial outcomes of immediate LLETZ and punch biopsies with selective recall.

Supporting Evidence

  • Women with low-grade abnormal cytology are often referred for colposcopy, which can cause distress.
  • Immediate treatment by LLETZ can lead to overtreatment and potential risks.
  • Psychosocial outcomes were measured using validated instruments like HADS and IES.

Takeaway

This study looked at how different treatments for women with abnormal cervical tests affect their feelings over time, and found that both treatments have similar effects on mental health.

Methodology

Women were randomized to immediate LLETZ or punch biopsies with recall for treatment based on biopsy results, and their psychosocial outcomes were assessed at multiple time points.

Potential Biases

There may be participation bias affecting the results, as response rates varied by anxiety and depression levels.

Limitations

The study may underestimate the overall frequency of significant anxiety due to lower participation among younger women.

Participant Demographics

Participants were women aged 20-59, with a majority being white and in employment; 43% were aged 20-29.

Statistical Information

P-Value

0.067

Confidence Interval

0.52–1.17

Statistical Significance

p=0.067

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1038/sj.bjc.6606042

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication