Validity of Self-Reported Sedentary Behavior in Adolescents
Author Information
Author(s): Olivia Affuso, June Stevens, Diane Catellier, Robert G McMurray, Dianne S Ward, Leslie Lytle, Melinda S Sothern, Deborah R Young
Primary Institution: University of Alabama at Birmingham
Hypothesis
Weight status and sex would influence reporting of sedentary behaviors among adolescents trying to avoid social criticism.
Conclusion
The modified 3-day Self-Administered Physical Activity Checklist is not a reliable method for assessing sedentary behavior in adolescents.
Supporting Evidence
- Adolescents generally underestimated minutes of sedentary behavior compared to accelerometry-measured minutes.
- The overall correlation between self-reported and accelerometry-measured sedentary behavior was weak.
- Overweight girls reported fewer minutes of sedentary behavior than normal weight girls, but this was not supported by accelerometry data.
- Self-reported minutes of TV/video watching were significantly correlated with accelerometer data in normal weight and overweight girls.
- Normal weight boys reported significantly fewer minutes of sedentary behavior compared to accelerometry.
Takeaway
This study found that teens often underestimate how much time they spend being inactive, and the way they report this isn't very accurate.
Methodology
The study compared self-reported sedentary behavior using a modified questionnaire with accelerometer data over three days.
Potential Biases
Response bias may have influenced self-reported data, particularly among overweight adolescents.
Limitations
Sedentary behavior was not assessed during school hours, which may have affected the results.
Participant Demographics
The sample included 201 adolescents (128 girls and 73 boys) aged 11-15 years, with 36% classified as overweight and a diverse ethnic background.
Statistical Information
P-Value
0.0009
Confidence Interval
95% CI 0.05, 0.23
Statistical Significance
p<0.05
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website