A community experiment with fully open and published peer review
2006
Launching Biology Direct: A New Open Access Journal
Editorial
Author Information
Author(s): Koonin Eugene V, Landweber Laura F, Lipman David J
Conclusion
Biology Direct aims to improve the peer review process by allowing open and published reviews alongside articles.
Supporting Evidence
- Biology Direct will publish articles even with negative reviews if three Editorial Board members agree to review them.
- The journal aims to revive open discussions in the scientific community.
- Anonymity in peer review can lead to biased reviews, but it is seen as necessary for critical feedback.
Takeaway
Biology Direct is a new journal where scientists can publish their work along with reviews, making the process more open and transparent.
Potential Biases
There is a risk of biased reviews due to the anonymity of the peer review process.
Limitations
The journal may publish flawed research and could devolve into a self-serving club if not managed properly.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website